So anyone that knows me, know that I've been beyond stoked about not just the reunion of Sunny Day Real Estate (and ecstatic about the rumors of another record.....), but about the fact that they were coming to Dallas. Yes, I was prepared to shell out whatever it cost to fly somewhere else in the country, if need be, to see them. And yes, I was quite thrilled that instead of that, they decided to play a mile from my house. Seriously, I bought tickets 3m after they went on sale and I've been counting down the days to Oct. 5. I detailed here how and why I got into SDRE, but the fact remains, I was excited about the show. So last night was the night, and I went, and.....
IT WAS FUCKING AWESOME!!!
Seriously, it was better than even I expected. And a simple straw poll of the audience, reflected a similar sentiment. My first observation, say about 30s into Friday was that it was really, really loud. To put things in perspective, not a week earlier I'd gotten a free ticket to go see The Get-Up Kids at the same venue, and while I was never a huge Get-Up Kids fan, I was intrigued.
SDRE simply blew them out of the water. It was the loudest show I've seen since Local H at the Galaxy Club back in 1997 (that show left me hearing static for 3 days), and that's from a guy that's seen Tool, Pantera, Metallica, and more punk bands than you can shake a stick at. It was freaking loud, but not unnecessarily loud....you could hear the notes, you could hear the harmonies, it was just that when they were rocking.....they were rocking. And when it was melodic, well, it was still rocking.
I did a little google research before the show, and so I was prepared for the fact that other than Guitar And Video Games, the rest of the songs would be off of Diary and LP2. Understandable, since this was the first reunion of all 4 members since those records, though I won't deny hoping to hear a little of The Rising Tide. They were on point, hitting every note and I was shocked to hear that Jeremy Enigk still had the ability to hit both alto and falsetto notes at his age (I wrongly assumed his solo stuff had been engineered a bit), and was likewise surprised to hear William Goldsmith rocking out so many fills on the drums.
At one point, my brother's girlfriend remarked to me, "this sounds just like the record!" and I think that's an apt description. There was a little artistic license taken, especially on drums, but all in all they were on....it was as moving, as powerful, and as loud as the records. And it was the best show I've seen in a long time.
Just in case anyone reading this is doing so by googling reviews of the show (as I did....), below is the setlist hear in Dallas. It's also worth noting that they made mention of the possibilities of both being back, and of recording new material, so don't real that out.
Friday
Seven
Song About An Angel
Grendel
Guitar And Video Games
Iscarabaid
Theo B
5/4
10 (i think? it was a new song?)
Sometimes
Circles
J'Nuh
Pictures from the Wine Trail in 2009
2 hours ago



